Told Your Cash Advance App Isn’t a ‘Loan’? Why You May Be Owed a Full Refund of Every Fee You Paid
Quick Answer: Can I get a refund of fees paid to cash advance apps?
Yes. If a court determines that a cash advance app is actually a lender, its ‘fees’ and ‘tips’ are legally considered interest. In New York, if this interest exceeds the 16% usury cap, the entire loan contract may be void, and you may be entitled to a full refund of all fees paid.
Told Your Cash Advance App Isn’t a ‘Loan’? Why You May Be Owed a Full Refund
Fintech apps like Dave, EarnIn, and MoneyLion often use a specific legal defense to avoid regulation: they claim they aren’t “lenders” and their advances aren’t “loans.” Instead, they call them “non-recourse transfers” or “earned wage access.”
By avoiding the “loan” label, they attempt to bypass the Truth in Lending Act (TILA) and state usury laws. But the law looks at the substance of a transaction, not just the label the company puts on it.
The “Not a Loan” Defense Is Crumbling
Courts and regulators are increasingly seeing through this wordplay. If an app provides you money that you are expected to pay back (usually via an automatic debit on your next payday), it is extending credit.
If it is credit, then:
- Usury Caps Apply: In New York, the civil usury limit is 16% APR. If your “tips” and “express fees” add up to more than that, the loan is usurious.
- TILA Disclosures Are Mandatory: The app must provide a clear, written disclosure of the APR. Almost none of them do.
Why You May Be Owed a Full Refund
Under New York law (N.Y. Gen. Oblig. Law § 5-511), a loan that violates the usury cap is void from the beginning. This means the lender has no legal right to collect the principal or the interest.
If we can prove the app is a lender:
- Restitution: You can seek a refund of every “tip,” “service fee,” and “express fee” you have ever paid to the app.
- Debt Cancellation: Any current balance you owe could be wiped out entirely.
- Statutory Penalties: Under TILA, you can seek additional damages for the failure to provide proper disclosures.
How We Prove It
We look for “Dark Patterns” in the app’s design. For example, if the app makes it difficult to “opt-out” of a tip, or if “Express Delivery” is the only way to get the money in time to pay a bill, those fees are not truly optional—they are the cost of credit.
If you have paid hundreds of dollars in fees to these apps over the last year, you aren’t just a customer; you may be a victim of predatory lending with a right to a full refund.
Need Legal Help with This Issue?
If you are facing this problem, you may have a claim for statutory damages. Our intake process is digital, secure, and encrypted.